Lullabies for Sweet Dreams: Our Top Picks for Best Baby Mattresses

Baby crib mattress

As parents, we understand the importance of creating a nurturing environment for our little ones to rest and recharge. That's why we've meticulously curated this guide to help you find the perfect mattress for your baby's crib. From plush comfort to optimal support, each mattress on our list is carefully selected to ensure a safe and peaceful sleep for your precious bundle of joy. Say goodbye to sleepless nights and hello to sweet dreams with our expert recommendations.

Our Best Buy

The Graco Premium Crib Mattress stands out as the best buy in crib mattresses due to its outstanding certifications, safety, and quality. With Greenguard Gold certification and PTPA recognition, parents can trust this product. A waterproof and machine-washable cover aids in easy maintenance, while the breathable yet firm foam core ensures a sound sleep for your baby. Despite being single-sided, its compatibility with any standard full-size crib or toddler bed paired with a 6-year warranty exemplifies its longevity and value at just $89.99.

Ad
Win an Arenti Baby Monitor

Best Crib Mattresses for Baby

Graco Mattress

Graco Premium Crib Mattress

Price: $89.99

Buy Now From Amazon

Our Review

The Graco Premium Crib Mattress is a first-rate choice for a crib mattress. With esteemed certifications and awards--including a GREENGUARD Gold Certification and Parent Tested Parent Approved (PTPA) recognition--the safety and quality offered by this mattress are reassuring. Beyond this, the removable, waterproof, machine-washable cover ensures effortless maintenance. The perforated foam core strikes a balance between maximum breathability and firmness for a soothing sleep environment.

Comfortably accommodating any standard full-size crib or toddler bed, the dimensions are 52 inches in length, 28 inches in width, and 4.5 inches in height. Endorsed by a 6-year limited warranty, this mattress is a trustworthy, long-lasting option for your child.

What we like

  • GREENGUARD Gold, Formaldehyde Free, and CertiPUR-US certifications for guaranteed peace of mind.
  • Easy-to-clean removable, machine-washable cover with a waterproof sleep surface.
  • Breathable foam core design without compromising support.
  • Comfortably accommodates any standard full-size crib or toddler bed, extending its lifespan.
  • Free of fiberglass and chemical flame retardants.

Things to consider

This mattress is not dual-sided, which could decrease its appeal for those who prefer the option of flipping the mattress. Additionally, some reviews have mentioned a chemical smell from the mattress, which typically dissipates with time.

Useful product information

  • Product Dimensions: 52 x 27.6 x 4.5 inches.
  • Maximum Weight Recommendation: 50 Pounds.
  • Material Type: Foam.
  • Care Instructions: Machine Washable.
Milliard Memory Foam Crib Mattress

Milliard Memory Foam Crib Mattress

Price: $103.99

Buy Now From Amazon

Our Review

A perfect blend of comfort and safety, the Milliard Memory Foam Crib Mattress offers versatility to new parents. It features unique Flip Technology with a firm side for infants and a soft side for older babies and toddlers, designed to cater to your child's needs as they grow. To ensure maximum hygiene, it comes with a 100% cotton cover that is waterproof and washable, protecting the mattress from potential stains and spills. 

This safety-tested mattress meets or exceeds all US safety standards, built using CertiPur-certified foam. High-density construction ensures the product retains its shape over time while fitting standard cribs and toddler beds with dimensions of 52 x 27½ x 5.5 inches.

What we like

  • Flip Technology features a firm side for infants and a plush memory foam side for older children as they grow.
  • Comes with a soft and comfortable 100% cotton waterproof cover, making clean-up simple and easy after any accidents.
  • Meets or exceeds all US safety standards.
  • High-density construction ensures longevity and supports your child throughout their use of this product.

Things to consider

Based on a handful of reviews, the product may not be fully waterproof. Despite having a waterproof cover, some leakage and staining have been an issue for a few customers--meaning additional cleaning steps might be required to maintain its condition. However, most customers expressed satisfaction with the product's performance.

Useful product information

  • Dimensions: 52 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches.
  • Weight: 8.8 pounds.
Dream On Me Sunset Mattress

Dream On Me Sunset Crib Mattress

Price: $33.87

Buy Now From Amazon

Our Review

This mattress is the ideal option for parents seeking a portable crib mattress that offers both comfort and support. It is Greenguard Gold Certified and surpasses all safety standards set by CPSC/ASTM. It passes all flammability, phthalates, lead, and toxicity tests, offering you peace of mind while your baby snoozes. 

The mattress's fiber core is one of its most impressive features, offering a sturdy foundation and exceptional support for your baby. Its waterproof vinyl cover enhances the product's durability, ensuring its easy cleaning and maintenance. It is lightweight, making it convenient to change bedding, and made with high-density foam for added comfort. This product is proudly made in the USA using top-notch, environmentally friendly materials. With its optimal support, quality construction, and attention to safety, this mattress is worth considering for your child's sleep and overall well-being.

What we like

  • Passes all necessary safety standards and is Greenguard Gold Certified, offering the best in terms of health and safety for your baby.
  • Fiber core delivers a sturdy base and exceptional support for your little one.
  • Durable, waterproof vinyl cover can easily be cleaned with soap and water.
  • With its weight of just 2.5 pounds, handling this mattress is a breeze.
  • Square corners for a snug fit in mini/portable cribs.

Things to consider

Some customers have noted that the mattress is firmer than they expected. If you prefer a softer mattress for your baby, this may not be the best option for you. However, remember that firmness is intentional to provide maximum support to your child's growing body.

Useful product information

  • Dimensions: 38 x 24 x 3 inches.
  • Thickness: 3 inches.
  • Fabric Type: Vinyl.
  • Fabric Care Instructions: Wipe with a damp cloth.
Ad
Win an Arenti Baby Monitor
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress

Price: $67.99

Buy Now From Amazon

Our Review

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress provides optimum comfort for your little ones. Its high-density thermo-bonded polyester fiber core provides ultra-firm support and maximizes airflow to guarantee a cool and restful night’s sleep for your baby. It meets the recommended mattress firmness to provide infants with safe sleep for their growing bodies. In addition, its waterproof and stain-resistant 100% vinyl cover is tear-resistant and locks out nighttime accidents or spills. 

The mattress is lightweight, making rotating it or changing sheets easy. With a Greenguard Gold Certification, you know it is free of harmful chemicals. Safety 1st is a trusted brand, receiving the Women’s Choice Award for America’s Most Recommended Brand as well as Best Crib Mattress of 2022 by U.S. News 360 Reviews. Supported by a 10-year limited warranty, this product promises safety and durability.

What we like

  • 100% vinyl cover is waterproof and resists stains, facilitating a dry and hygienic sleeping environment for your baby.
  • High-density polyester fiber core offers maximum airflow, keeping your baby comfortable throughout the night.
  • Firm to provide optimal support and a safe sleeping surface for your growing baby.
  • Fits standard-size cribs and toddler beds with ease.
  • Greenguard Gold Certified due to its low-chemical emissions and high-quality air testing and free from harmful chemicals, PVC, lead, and phthalates.

Things to consider

Some customers have reported that the mattress cover can wear down after a year, or cause problems with temperature regulation. These are isolated incidents and your experience may vary. Overall, this mattress offers excellent value for the features it provides.

Useful product information

  • Product Dimensions: 52 x 27.5 x 5 inches.
  • Item Weight: 7.5 pounds.
  • Material Type: 100% Vinyl.
  • Care Instructions: Wipe clean with a damp cloth.
Serta Mattress

Serta Perfect Start Crib Mattress

Price: $74.99

Buy Now From Amazon

Our Review

The Serta Perfect Start Crib Mattress is an exceptional choice for new parents seeking quality and reliability. Its firm design with a sustainably sourced fiber core made from upcycled plastic bottles ensures your baby enjoys a safe sleep. It’s lightweight and filled with memory foam for added comfort and mobility. 

The waterproof cover is an added bonus, protecting against potential accidents and simplifying cleanup. Both sides are covered so you can flip the mattress when your baby grows into a toddler. Additionally, it possesses the Greenguard Gold certification, meaning it meets the stringent standards for minimal chemical emissions. Investing in this mattress allows you to concentrate closely on nurturing your little one, backed by the reassurance that they're sleeping soundly.

What we like

  • High-quality sustainably sourced firm fiber core promotes longer, healthier sleep for your baby and young child.
  • Both sides feature a waterproof cover, ensuring easy cleaning and maintained freshness.
  • Greenguard Gold certified, indicating it adheres to the highest standards for reduced chemical emissions.
  • Square-cornered and lightweight design for a snug fit in a toddler bed or crib.

Things to consider

While this mattress has many great qualities, it's worth mentioning some customers have reported concerns about breathability since the mattress is extremely firm. Nevertheless, for newborns and young infants, this mattress remains an excellent choice.

Useful product information

  • Dimensions: 52 x 27.5 x 6 inches.
  • Weight: 10.63 pounds.
  • Height: Less than 6 inches (fits standard cribs and toddler beds).
Newton Crib Mattress

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Price: $299.99

Buy Now From Amazon

Our Review

The Newton Baby Crib Mattress offers both safety and supreme comfort for babies. This mattress promotes healthier sleep by enabling your infant to breathe through it easily with breathe-thru technology. The supportive core is made up of 90% air and 10% yoghurt-cup material and encased in a soft, detachable cover. 

To make it even more enticing, the mattress is 100% washable, making it convenient to maintain cleanliness and hygiene for the long term. Designed by parents, for parents, this mattress puts your baby's safety at the forefront.

What we like

  • Remarkable breathability provided by innovative breathe-thru technology.
  • 100% washable, ensuring hygiene and comfort for your little one.
  • Extra layers of comfort and support designed to uphold your baby's natural posture.
  • Prioritizes safety and comfort, made by parents for parents.

Things to consider

A potential downside to this mattress is its price of $299.99. This could be a pivotal concern, depending on your budget. Nevertheless, the product's quality, safety features, and durability make it a worthwhile investment in your baby's health and sleep comfort.

Useful product information

  • Product Dimensions: 52 x 28 x 5.5 inches.
  • Item Weight: 11 pounds.
Sealy Mattress

Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress

Price: $89.99

Buy Now From Amazon

Our Review

The Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress is a standout option for first-time parents seeking a trustworthy and comfortable mattress. Its 204-coil innerspring system coupled with anti-sag distribution bars ensures top-tier support and firmness. Memory foam provides lightweight, airy comfort and support throughout. 

The mattress cover is antibacterial, waterproof, EPA-registered, lab-tested, tear-resistant, and stain-resistant to help keep the inside clean and sanitary. Additionally, the product is Greenguard Gold certified and passes firmness and durability tests, ASTM, CPSIA, and harsh chemical standards. Sealy is a renowned leader in sleep technology and a best-seller in North America's crib mattress market--this product is one you know you can trust.

What we like

  • EPA-registered, lab-tested waterproof cover helps curb bacterial spread and maintain a clean, stain-free mattress.
  • Premium network of 204 interwoven support coils augmented by steel edges guarantees all-round firmness and support.
  • Anti-sag weight distribution system is centrally located where infants spend most of their time, giving added support.
  • Made with environmentally-friendly materials, it offers lightweight, cushiony comfort and support for your baby.

Things to consider

The mattress possesses numerous excellent characteristics, though a few customers have noted that it produces some noise when the baby moves. If your child is easily disturbed by sounds, you may want to factor this into your decision.

Useful product information

  • Product Dimensions: 51.63 x 27.25 x 5.75 inches.
  • Item Weight: 7.51 pounds.

Frequently Asked Questions

The price range for crib mattresses can vary, but it's important to consider quality and safety. You can generally find good-quality crib mattresses from around $80 to $100. If you have a larger budget, investing in a higher-end mattress with features like dual-sided firmness or organic materials can provide additional benefits. Remember, while price is important, prioritize safety, comfort, and durability when choosing a crib mattress for your baby.

Safety should be your top priority when choosing a crib mattress. Look for mattresses that are firm, flat, and fit snugly into the crib to reduce the risk of suffocation or Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). Consider mattresses with breathable materials to enhance air circulation. Waterproof or water-resistant covers are also helpful for easy cleaning. Additionally, prioritize mattresses made from hypoallergenic materials and certified for low chemical emissions to promote a healthy sleep environment for your baby. Mattresses with dual-sided firmness can offer versatility as your baby grows.